Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - PeterNSteinmetz

Pages: 1 ... 20 21 [22] 23 24 ... 47
316
Spin Zone / Re: 2000 Mules
« on: June 04, 2022, 08:37:36 PM »
Does anyone know of an objective written summary of the evidence presented in this film and criticism of it.

Certainly the AP report does not look good in terms of veracity - https://apnews.com/article/e1b49d2311bf900f44fa5c6dac406762

317
Spin Zone / Re: My history with trans
« on: April 21, 2022, 09:41:00 AM »
I would say gender reassignment is extreme enough for society to intervene, but only because more harm will be done to non-true TGs.  Unfortunately this results in more harm to true TGs who will now be denied the opportunity to get early treatment. 

Very nice analysis with which I completely agree. I think the quoted part is a very good libertarian way to look at it for minors.

Adults should be allowed to mutilate themselves if they wish. I'm not sure I would want to belong to a medical society that encouraged or facilitated it though.

318
Spin Zone / Re: My history with trans
« on: April 21, 2022, 08:20:12 AM »
So from a libertarian perspective do you take away the freedom of the one to protect the five and the hundred?  Public policy is “yes”.  After all, they want to force vaccination on all of us to protect the 1% who die of Covid.  If the left justifies that, how much more should they support banning children from transitioning?  The harm to the majority from gender dysphoria misdiagnosis is way more than the risk of vaccine side effects.

A very thoughtful and interesting post. I don't think we have a legal right to stop adults from doing what they want to themselves. But prior to 18, in our society, we hold that minors do not have full legal rights. The age can be debated and perhaps a more transitioned approach would be better. But for minors I think of the question as whether we recognize those rights, not whether we take them away.

319
Spin Zone / Re: My history with trans
« on: April 21, 2022, 08:06:51 AM »
correction:  the person's gender is not altered.  The person's body is mutilated, but until some time in the sci-fi future when you can replace the XY with XX or XX with XY, the gender isn't changed.

You're right Bob, perhaps I should have said that I think taking permanent measures to alter someone's apparent gender or sex is a bad idea. It is a form of mutilation. When I first started medical school we were taught that there was no good evidence this actually helped the patient psychologically or psychiatrically. Therefore it was not ethical to perform such procedures.

320
Spin Zone / Re: My history with trans
« on: April 20, 2022, 09:27:22 PM »
As a libertarian I am firmly against the government interfering in medical decisions parents make for their children.

As you know, I am also solidly libertarian. But a I think a case can be made that there are some medical decisions a parent should not be allowed to make for a child.

Classic example is a Jehovah’s Witness parent refusing a life saving blood transfusion for the child.

I am not quite sure where sex change falls on this spectrum. I think that taking permanent measures to alter gender before a person is a full adult is rather serious. And of course teenage brains are overrun with all sorts of hormonal overloads.

OTOH, people seriously suffering for years from puberty through 18 is a lot.

The other thing which concerns me is that my understanding from some years back is that transitioning does not cure the dysphoria in a reliable way.

321
There’s Mooney Michael, and there’s the other Michael.  You’re bringing them together.  That’s a no-no.  You’re killing Independent Michael.  We have to keep our worlds separate.
My pleasure.

322
Does he cover that in chapter 12 of his book "For a New Liberty" or is there a separate discussion he made somewhere else on the subject?

It has been covered in his other works over the years, but yes, chapter 12 of that book is the pertinent one.

323
Agree wholeheartedly with the bold parts. The rest I don't disagree with but need to study more.
I will be keen to hear what you think of Rothbard’s ideas on this point, when you have the time.

324

A free market economy like ours trends toward monopolies as economies of scale cause small businesses to gobble each other up until they become one large black hole which is allied with the political class.


Of course we are presently very far from a free market economy. It is quite mixed.

The point about evolution is a good one. I think the only way to prevent such capture is strong limitations on government power. But as the history of the US shows, that may not so much prevent as merely slow down.

I rather like Rothbard’s ideas about competing organizations to provide use of defensive force. Without a geographic monopoly, people can then switch defense providers if one gets out of control.

Of course this raises other potential problems. Personally I don’t think we have enough experience and data at the low end of the violence in society scale to really know if such geographic monopolies are the best way to go or not. Essentially that is the classic minarchism vs anarchy debate.

What I am fairly certain of is that our current Federal government is at least 10X too large and is a creeping monster destructive of our freedoms.

325
Discussion of Michael Weinstein's prop strike moved to its' own thread. http://www.pilotspin.com/index.php?topic=6303.0

326
Copied from the other thread:

Edited with updated information.

Micheal Weinstein does own a Mooney M20C in an LLC. N6475U .

This aircraft was involved in a crash back in 75, but nothing the NTSB more recently. https://www.ntsb.gov/Pages/brief.aspx?ev_id=47053&key=0 . That crash does not appear to be the incident he is referring to since the pilot in that crash was 58 at the time.

He seems to have a very different persona on mooneyspace. Perhaps because he is known there?

Here is a thread titled "I should really think about giving up this aviation thing", dated Aug 28, 2017. It mentions the prop strike as being previous. https://mooneyspace.com/topic/23693-i-should-really-think-about-giving-up-this-aviation-thing/#comment-376115

In a way, this seems more curious to me. He has this fairly humble friendly persona then comes on PoA, PS, and PB with all these fallacies and is very hostile.

327
Since a number of posters have indicated an interest in Michael Weinstein's (aka steingar) prop strike accident in the V35B gear collapse thread, I thought I would move that separate discussion to its own thread.

This from a thread in mooneyspace in December 2017 titled "About time I fessed up" (https://mooneyspace.com/topic/23693-i-should-really-think-about-giving-up-this-aviation-thing/#comment-376115)

"August 2016 I was delivering my Mooney M20c to my mechanic, Bobby Norman, at the Parr airport (42I) in Zanesville Ohio. I had interaction with Bobby years ago, and he came highly recommended by a number of local Mooney owners.  I had thought the field was about 2300 feet (wrong, more on that later) so coming in over the trees I pulled the power to idle, put it in a forward slip and came down.  75mph over the numbers, flared and BANG!.  Hardest landing I'd ever done in anything.  At the top of the bounce I had a choice, and decided to ride it out. I was uncomfortable trying to go around at a short strip in that predicament.  The aircraft bounced a couple more times and stopped, and I taxied back.  I had struck the prop in that landing, quite badly.

The prop was bent asymmetrically, and the craskshaft busted.  I hit hard enough that the force went through the gear into the Johnson bar, wrecking the mechanism that holds it in place (Bobby only figured that part out when he started taxiing.  He said it was quite exciting)."

328
I can address that.  It’s the absent minded professor syndrome.  My father had it.  I suppose it would sound like bragging if I said I have it but I believe I do.  I can be extremely blind and unperceptive about things around me because my mind is constantly occupied with complex analysis of some topic or another.  I think it actually made me a worse pilot, because I tend to over analyze, rather than make quick decisions. 

It also leads people to extrapolate all possible futures and hence have more anxiety than the average person about the various consequences of your action or inaction.  You can then become overly focused on one thing or another, I believe Michael admits being “paranoid” about gear up landings.  He doesn’t mean literal psychotic paranoia, but perhaps a bit closer to a neurotic obsession.  Smart people can be quite high in neuroticism because they see reality with all its dangers more acutely than the “fat, dumb, and happy.”

Rather insightful about the possible obsession on gear up landings. But does that explain the numerous fallacies of this nature on other topics?

329
He can give the full details if he cares, but the TL;DR version is he porpoised the Mooney on landing and had a prop strike.
I see. He mentioned that back in the old Air Wagner thread. Seems he was forthright about it and took a lot of training to improve. All good things.

What is honestly more puzzling to me is the constant fallacies in a person who has professional scientific training. But oh well, I digress from the main point here which was to possibly help others understand and avoid similar issues with gear collapses. Particularly if moving between different aircraft types.

330
Exactly, and Micheal is not immune to landing issues as I recall.
Is that right? Interesting. Are there more details which would be useful for others to learn from?

Pages: 1 ... 20 21 [22] 23 24 ... 47