Rush is RIGHT.

There is not a thing about his responses that is gibberish, though I know you wish it were so.

There is a Libertarian case for free movement of people and open borders, and, therefore, an opportunity for you to understand their case and then destroy it point-by-point. This will require posting more than a single-frame cartoon or meme, though.

You miss opportunity for great discussion by reverting to toddler-esque debate tactics.

Argumentum ad hominem.

S.744 – Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act

Introduced by CHUCK SCHUMER
April 16, 2013
Passed Senate: YEAs 68 / NAYs 32

It passed the Senate but no comparable bill made it out of committee in the House that was found in searching. This bill took 4 submissions and 554 amendments to be completed.

CBO findings: (Even they recognized the bill had more needed than Schumer submitted.)

Introduction to the Bill:

(1) The passage of this Act recognizes that the primary tenets of its success depend on securing the sovereignty of the United States of America and establishing a coherent and just system for integrating those who seek to join American society.

(2) We have a right, and duty, to maintain and secure our borders, and to keep our country safe and prosperous. As a Nation founded, built and sustained by immigrants we also have a responsibility to harness the power of that tradition in a balanced way that secures a more prosperous future for America.

(3) We have always welcomed newcomers to the United States and will continue to do so. But in order to qualify for the honor and privilege of eventual citizenship, our laws must be followed. The world depends on America to be strong—economically, militarily and ethically. The establishment of a stable, just, and efficient immigration system only supports those goals. As a Nation, we have the right and responsibility to make our borders safe, to establish clear and just rules for seeking citizenship, to control the flow of legal immigration, and to eliminate illegal immigration, which in some cases has become a threat to our national security.

(4) All parts of this Act are premised on the right and need of the United States to achieve these goals, and to protect its borders and maintain its sovereignty.

The bill makes significant additional investments in border security, including: $3 billion for the Border Security Results Strategy (consultations and recommendations by the new expensive commission); $2 billion to carry out the Commission’s recommendations (slush fund to carry out their recommendations); $1,5 billion for fencing, infrastructure, personnel, and technology (this is in addition to all of the personnel, equipment etc. mentioned below); $750 million for E-Verify (which eventually faded out); funds for the hiring of 3,500 CBP officers; funds for increasing prosecution of border crossing violations; enhancements to state law-enforcement preparedness through Operation Stonegarden for combating illegal immigration and drug smuggling; 24-hour surveillance of the southwest border region using video, unmanned aircraft, helicopters and watercraft; expanded reimbursement of states’ costs of detention of unauthorized immigrants; and training of CBP, Border Patrol, and ICE officers. The salaries of border contractors will have caps.

What is not noted is that 2 Trust Funds were to be set up. Also we saw exactly what they considered fencing. Which barely registers or keeps a goat much less a person from going over or through what they wanted built. The very wording that Schumer supplied to submit the bill says that he demanded strong borders and why it was needed. Do what is needed.