12061
Spin Zone / Re: Can someone explain how anyone could endorse socialism?
« on: April 26, 2017, 01:04:20 PM »Intelligent Moderate? You think about your positions?
A thought on the original topic - Socialism is doomed to be defeated by the forces of economics. Under socialism, everyone is basically equal, so every person has an equal claim on resources. However there will never be enough to go around, so not everyone can have what they want. The result must be shortages and therefore misery.
Ergo, socialism is an inferior system.
Intelligent moderate, maybe. I do think about them, in fact, I endeavor to apply logic, facts and reality before I decide on my position on an issue, and it can change if I get new information. For example, I used to be for capital punishment. Then I found out about corrupt prosecutors and a high rate of innocent people being put to death in my state as a result of those prosecutors, so I became against it, in that context. But in principle I am for it. It's just that I figured out that, like in so many things, government can be stupid, corrupt and wrong when it tries to do something, and I feel strongly about protecting the innocent from wrong convictions.
Actually, I am in favor of capital punishment at the point of the crime's commission. In other words, by the would-be victim. And it should apply to any crime of personal assault of body or property. For example, that flash mob train robbery the other day. The riders should have been armed and should have mowed down those thugs, rather than turn over their wallets and cell phones. So I have no problem with death as a penalty for crime. But whether I would vote for or against the death penalty in the context of our criminal justice system, would all depend. Is DNA technology significantly advanced that the conviction of innocent people has drastically been reduced? Are there safeguards against corrupt prosecutors? I don't know, I'd have to look at it when it was put before me.
So what do you call that? You can hardly call it "moderate" when I advocate blasting to Hell a 14 year old trying to grab my purse, as my ideological position. That's pretty extreme. But since I cannot tell you how I'd vote on the issue, would you say I'm on the fence, or technically moderate on the issue?
I agree with your statement about socialism.